Sunday, October 16, 2011

Yet I Do Marvel-Countee Cullen


In Cullen’s Yet I Do Marvel, Cullen essentially questions God. In the opening line, Cullen states that he doesn’t doubt that God is good and kind, but continues by questioning why God made some things the way they are. For instance, Cullen asks why people die, and why moles are blind. Cullen relates his questioning of God to the story of Tantalus, who was placed chin deep in water with fruit above his head, just out of his reach. This way he could get neither food nor water although they were right in front of him teasing him. Cullen also uses the story of Sisyphus, who had to walk up never-ending stairs.

Cullen essentially gives a voice to the way a lot of people feel. We all wonder why some things are the way they are because they don’t always make sense to us. Cullen says, “Inscrutable His ways are…” We can’t fathom why God does what he does. Some things in life are just not meant to be figured out in my opinion. It’s just the way things are.

I like the use of Cullen’s word quibble in the second line. To quibble is to evade an argument with a long-winded and ambiguous answer. Cullen says if you question God, he will just evade answering the question
The last line of the poem confused me. Is this a reference to the first movies, when actors were always white and they would paint their faces black?

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock-T.S. Eliot


Oh boy another work by T.S. Eliot. These things are deep! I know we talked about the importance of the epigraph in class, but I just don’t get it. Maybe my translation is wrong?

“If I thought my answer were given
  to anyone who would ever return to the world
              this flame would stand still without moving any further.
              But since never from this abyss has anyone ever returned alive; if what I hear is true
              without fear of infamy I answer you.”

So, in short, what I think The Love Song is about is an insecure middle-aged man trying to work up the courage to talk to a woman or women and the myriad and jumble of thoughts that go on while he is thinking of how to approach them, what he is going to say, etc. The man continuously second-guesses himself. For instance, in lines 40-44, the man thinks to himself about his bald spot and dress and speculates that the women will make fun of his thinning hair and thin arms and legs. Again the man’s lack of confidence is shown in the paragraph that starts at line 55. The man speaks of “the eyes that fix you in a formulated phrase…” He obviously thinks the women have already judged him before he’s even spoken to them. The man admires the women’s beauty and smell in the paragraph that starts at line 63, and continues to go back and forth debating when and if he should talk with the women. Should he just be aggressive? Should he wait until after tea? Will it be worth it? All the man can think about is what can go wrong and not about any sort of positive outcome. At one point (paragraph beginning at line 111), the man begins to list some of his good qualities, but ultimately second-guesses himself again, saying he is “…ridiculous…” and “…the Fool.”

I think the paragraph that starts at line 122 really highlights the fact Eliot is playing on the sporadic nature of the human thought process.  The man thinks, “Shall I part my hair behind? Do I dare to eat a peach?” His mind jumps from one thing to another in a random manner.

I think the first couple of paragraphs simply set up the mood and setting. I’m not entirely sure about the first paragraph, but I think it presents a question to which Eliot is seemingly going to answer in the poem. What is the significance of the recurring lines, “In the room the women come and go/Talking of Michelangelo?” The next paragraph aids in the setting. In my mind, it painted a foggy town during twilight in October.

One of my favorite lines in the poem is line 27. “To prepare a face to meet the faces that you meet…” I think Eliot is speaking about how we always put up this initial front or guard to people when we meet them instead of just being ourselves.

I found myself a bit lost at the end. I couldn’t quite comprehend what Eliot was trying to say when he was finishing the poem. My best guess is that thoughts/imagination cease to exist when we are interrupted and snapped back to reality. Any ideas?

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

The Waste Land-T.S. Eliot


Burial of the Dead
It seemed to me like the first paragraph was about the narrator coming to Germany. She (Marie) talks about coming across the Stanberger See, which is a lake in Germany, and having coffee in the Hofgarten, a garden in Germany.
The second paragraph, to me, described the death of the little girl, Marie. I’m not sure what the shadow represents here, maybe the body, or maybe just something to entice the narrator to explore it. Lines 38 and beyond describe the death (or near death) of Marie, as someone had their “…arms full, and your hair wet…I was neither living nor dead…” The arms full and hair wet represent signified to me that someone rescued Marie from drowning and was carrying her in their arms.
Paragraph three appears to be Marie getting her fortune read by Madame Sosostris. Sosostris advises Marie to “fear death by water.” I would like to know if Marie got her fortune read before or after the events in the previous paragraph. Or is this even Marie getting her fortune read?
I think the final paragraph displayed the funeral of Marie while she was in limbo, neither living nor dead—a ghost, if you will. Here she calls out to someone she knows named Stetson. I believe he is her brother (mon frère). Marie asks about “that corpse you planted last year in our garden, has it begun to sprout?” I think the corpse Marie speaks of is actually a flower, or a bulb. If it is actually a corpse, I think Eliot is trying to show us that life is cyclical; much like Whitman did with his grass speech in Song of Myself.

A Game of Chess
This was a bit more confusing to me.  The poem starts by creating an eerie setting. In my mind, there is a woman sitting in a dark, candlelit room, surrounded by burning incense and fragrance. A nightingale calls out and scares the woman, whose “nerves are bad tonight.” Why are her nerves bad? I think she begins to talk to herself, maybe her conscience, or maybe she is a schizophrenic. She begins to talk about her plans for the next day, planning to take a shower and maybe play a game of chess. The narrator continues to talk and describes Lil’s husband coming home from war. I think the narrator’s husband may be coming home from war, too, and she is trying to plan out how she is going to act and talk with him since it’s been so long since she’s last seen him. I think the narrator is worried because while her husband Albert was away, she had an affair and had multiple children, and doesn’t know how Albert will react. She’s been spending his money on drugs, too. She knows Albert is going to leave her, and she’s dreading his return. Yet, when Albert finally comes home, they sit and eat a “hot gammon” together. I don’t understand the ending where they say good night to all these different people.

The Fire Sermon
The first paragraph speaks of friends of summer departing and leaving no trace of themselves. I’m not quite sure what the next paragraph is getting at. The rat may signify loneliness as it crawls over bones. Perhaps the narrator is overlooking a cemetery? I say the rat may signify loneliness because usually where there is one rat there are many, except in this instance.
The next paragraph goes on to talk about a man named Tiresias watching another man caress and grope a woman. Is he raping her because in the next paragraph, line 252, she says, “Well now that’s done:  and I’m glad it’s over.” I don’t know what the author was trying to convey with this scene.
The end of the poem describes the narrator’s view as he rides in a canoe through the city (I think).  The narrator also describes himself lying in a canoe, I’m guessing so he can’t be seen. He also says he was promised “a new start.” Is this maybe for raping the girl? Also, what is “Weialala leia/Wallala leialala?” This one really confused me!

Death by Water
This poem tells the story (sort of) of Phlebas the Phoenician. Phlebas met his death at sea. Since Phlebas died, he does not care about the “cry of gulls” or the “profit and loss.” The author compares death to a “whirlpool” where Phlebas “passed the stages of his age and youth.”
I think the author wants us to realize we are all equal, but we usually only see that in death. It didn’t matter whether Phlebas was “Gentile or Jew.” He was a human being, just like you and me. The final line asks us to “Consider Phlebas, who was once handsome and tall as you.” He was no more than another individual living his life.

What the Thunder Said
I don’t have a lot left in the tank for this one! While I was reading it, I got the feeling someone was trapped in the desert in dire need of water. The author’s constant wish for rock to be water put me on that path! Is the third person walking beside the people death? It’s here I get lost. Who is this woman, and what does she represent? When the author speaks of the “decayed hole in the mountain…” is he speaking of a grave? And who are Datta, Dayadhvam, and Damyata? And then the London bridges song reference? I definitely need this one explained to me!

Sunday, October 2, 2011

Huck Finn Chapter 14


Chapter 14 just had a lot of good discussion points in it for me. The King Solomon story I blogged about before was good, but another good discussion point to me came shortly after that when Huck and Jim were talking about a Frenchman speaking French. The argument takes place on pages 124-125. In the argument, Jim thinks it’s ridiculous that a Frenchman speaks a different language. He feels all men should speak the same way because all men are essentially equal. Huck argues that it’s natural for a Frenchman to talk differently. It is plain to see by the different stances of each character’s arguments how they feel. Huck considers the Frenchman to be a completely different individual, almost a different species if you will. He compares the Frenchman speaking French to that of a cat and a cow talking different from each other and from humans. Jim, on the other hand, considers it absurd for a Frenchman to talk in a different language because although he is of a different nationality, he is still a man. Jim sees all men as equals. 

It’s interesting to me to see the different viewpoints each of the characters has. Huck considers it natural to differentiate between humans based on something as small as the language they speak. Jim sees it differently. He refutes Huck’s argument that cats and cows should naturally talk differently from men because they aren’t men. A Frenchman is still a man, no matter how you look at it, and Jim considers him equal. Jim’s argument is much the same as his King Solomon argument in that it is very superficial and somewhat ignorant. However, Jim knows no better and still makes very good points.

Huckleberry Finn--King Solomon


One of my favorite parts in Huckleberry Finn is in chapter 14 when Huck and Jim discussed the story of King Solomon. The story Jim and Huck talk about is the story of the child. Two mothers were arguing over who was the true mother of the child. King Solomon decides that the best way to solve the problem is to cut the child in half, that way each of the mothers could have some of the child. However, his true reasoning was that the real mother, upon hearing that the child would be killed, would allow the child to go with the other woman so that it may survive. Jim seems to take this story very literally, “missing the point.” He sees no point in cutting the child in half because it serves no purpose. Huck continuously argues with Jim telling him not to take the story so literally, but to no avail. Jim argues that a man such as Solomon with hundreds of children considers them dispensable, while someone who had one or two wouldn’t willingly allow their child to be cut in two. Huck believes more along the religious viewpoint, digging deeper into the story while Jim takes the story more literally. This attests to the theme of religion versus superstition in Huckleberry Finn. Religion is nothing more than a set of beliefs that people live by, but so is superstition. Jim believes in superstition because that’s all he has ever learned and makes the most sense to him. Who is to say who is right in this argument? Like any good literature, King Solomon’s story can be looked at from many different angles, superficially or deep.

The War Prayer

I enjoyed reading this work, and not just because it was short! America is alight with patriotism as it prepares to go to war. Everyone in the country shows their enthusiasm--drums beat, fireworks crack, children play with toy guns. Those that oppose the war are stifled and shunned, showing the vast majority is in favor of the war.

The day before the troops are to head off to war happens to be a Sunday. All of the men, along with their families, friends, and supporters head to church. The preacher blesses the troops, asking God to "watch over...noble young soldiers...bless them, shield them...help them crush the foe." During the prayer, another man, dressed in a black robe with pale skin, comes to the altar and begins to scold the people and the prayer, saying there are two sides to it. By praying for their soldiers victory, they are also praying for the other sides defeat and devastation. The people deem the man a lunatic.

Was the man supposed to represent death or something like that? I also think the words he spoke were very true. People never really think about both sides of what they are asking because humans are so superficial. By praying for their own success and safety, the people neglect to think about what they are wishing upon the enemy:  slaughter, death, pain, destruction, and grief. This kind of reminds me of Huck Finn and his prayer lessons from Miss Watson. She tells Huck to pray for other people and not for himself because it's the right thing to do. Huck, like the people in the story, see no point in praying for anyone or anything else because it will not benefit themselves. Lastly, it was easier for the people to deem the man a lunatic so that they might rationalize why they shouldn't listen to him.